A leaking tank or a smell of gas comes first
Water pooling under the heater or dripping from the base usually means the tank has rusted through. A tank in that state can't be repaired. Close the cold water valve on the pipe going into the top of the heater. On an electric tank, switch off its breaker. On a gas tank, turn the control knob to off. Then call. A leaking tank is an emergency call, because it will keep leaking until the tank is empty.
Water coming from the pipe on the side of the tank is a different fault. That pipe comes from the temperature and pressure relief valve, which opens when the tank gets too hot or the pressure gets too high. Never cap it or plug it. Shut off the cold supply as above and have the valve and the tank checked.
If you smell gas near the heater, don't touch any light switch or the heater controls. Get everyone out of the house and call your gas supplier's emergency line from outside.
No hot water or too little usually has a simple cause
Electric tanks have two elements, each with its own thermostat. The lower element does most of the work, so it fails first, and in Fergus it is often found buried in scale. If you get some hot water but it runs out quickly, check the element. If you get none at all, check the breaker, the high-limit reset and the upper element.
On a gas tank, no hot water usually traces to the pilot, the flame sensor or thermocouple, or the gas valve. A heater that lights and then goes out can have a venting problem, which needs to be found before the heater is put back in use.
Rumbling or popping from the tank is water trapped under a layer of scale and boiling through it. Rusty hot water means the anode rod is used up or the tank is corroding. A rotten-egg smell from the hot taps only usually comes from the anode reacting with the water, and you can fix it by changing the rod.
Hard water is what ends most heaters in Fergus
The Township of Centre Wellington supplies Fergus with groundwater from municipal wells. It reports an average hardness of 540 mg/L as CaCO3, or 38 grains, and notes that the minerals cause scale in pipes and appliances. In a tank heater, that scale settles on the bottom and coats the elements. On a gas tank it sits between the burner and the water, so the steel runs hotter and the tank wears out sooner.
Flushing the tank about once a year takes out the loose sediment before it hardens. A water softener cuts down the scale, and the Township notes that many homes in town have one. Softened water uses up the anode rod faster, though, so a softened house should have the rod checked as well. In the newer houses in Storybrook the pipes are rarely the trouble; the usual calls are for scale in the water heater, the softener and the fixtures.
Tankless heaters heat water in a narrow heat exchanger, and hard water closes it up quickly. In Fergus a tankless unit needs isolation valves for descaling and a softener ahead of it, or it won't last. Our guide on water heaters and very hard water has more detail.
A replacement is sized to the household
Before recommending a heater, we ask how many people shower in the morning, whether there is a large tub, and whether the house runs on gas or electric. A tank that was right for two people can be too small for five. A tankless unit gives a steady supply but needs enough gas or electrical capacity and a place to vent.
The house matters too. In the stone houses on St. Andrew Street and Union Street West, the basement often has only a floor drain, so we check where water would go if the tank ever leaked. Many of the Victory homes around Webster Park were built without a basement. There the heater can sit in a utility room or a basement that was added later, and supply pipes may run where frost reaches them. We look at those pipes during the same visit.
Hot water at the shower and tub is limited to 49 °C
Ontario's Building Code (Part 7, Article 7.2.10.7.) limits water from a shower head or into a bathtub to 49 °C. A tank kept too cool can let bacteria grow, so the usual setup is to keep the tank hot and fit a mixing valve that brings the water down to a safe temperature at the fixtures. Young children and older adults scald fastest, so this matters most in houses where they live.
If your hot water feels scalding, or the tank has been turned down because it was too hot, we can check the setting and the mixing valve.
How a water heater job is done
We test before recommending anything: the elements or burner, the thermostat, the relief valve, the anode where it can be reached, and how much scale is in the tank. If a repair will make sense, we tell you. If the tank is near the end, we explain why. You see the price in writing and approve it before any part is fitted.
Work is performed by licensed plumbers (306A Certificate of Qualification). Gas work is performed by TSSA-certified gas technicians, which is what Ontario Regulation 212/01 asks for when a gas water heater is installed or serviced. Some replacements and changes to piping need a building permit. The Township's building department decides which jobs need one, and we tell you before work starts.
With a new heater, register it with the manufacturer and keep a record of each flush. Some manufacturer warranties depend on regular maintenance, and in 38-grain water you'll need that maintenance anyway. For other leaks and worn fixtures, see plumbing repairs.
